Our Story

The Reverend Andrew Wetzel founded Zion Church, Utica’s first Lutheran congregation, in 1842.  Pastor Wetzel had immigrated to Central New York from Germany in 1832.  Wetzel’s German-American parish was originally called “The United Evangelical Lutheran and German Reformed Congregation of the City of Utica.”

Zion’s first sanctuary was built in West Utica.  Services were initially spoken in German, with English services added in 1914.  During its early years, Zion housed an elementary school, and the church’s parish center served as a community hub, hosting drama presentations, German dinners, and festivals. The West Utica location served the church until it moved to French Road in New Hartford in 1959.

Zion’s members continue to value their German heritage.  The 1913 Robert Pietsch oak altar, with German and English inscriptions, resides at Zion today.  “Octoberfest” celebrations have been held over the years, and Zion maintains a relationship with a sister church in Germany.

In 2017, Zion Lutheran Church celebrated its 175th anniversary, which coincided with the 500th anniversary of the Protestant Reformation started by Martin Luther.  With its deep roots in the Utica area, Zion is well positioned to serve the surrounding communities for years to come.

For more information on Zion’s history, complimentary copies of Zion’s 175th anniversary commemorative publications are available in the Narthex.